Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCA2024-07A Future With A Past 26 February 2024 Grant & Amy Kirchhoff 324 Ruth Street Grapevine, TX 76051 214.668.1072 RE: HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS #CA24-07 HISTORIC 1953 WAYNE C. GOODENOUGH HOUSE D. E. BOX ADDITION HISTORIC DISTRICT 324 RUTH STREET GRAPEVINE, TEXAS 76051 This letter confirms on February 26, 2024 the Historic Preservation Staff approved with conditions #CA24-07 for the property addressed 324 Ruth Street, legally described as Block 6, lot 4, D. E. Box Addition, City of Grapevine to the Grapevine Historic Preservation Ordinance 91-73 (Appendix G — Grapevine Code of Ordinances), as amended, for the following: Install windows for the existing house and new additions using Pella Reserve, Traditional Series metal clad wood windows, white in color for both interior and exterior of window unit; as per the attached window schedule and specification sheets with the condition a permit is obtained from the Building Department. An approved Certificate of Appropriateness is not an approved building permit; a building permit is / is not required. Contact the City of Grapevine's Building Department at 8 410.3165 for fees and information regarding permits. Thank you, David Klempin Historic Preservation Officer THE CITY OF GRAPEVINE HISTORIC PRESERVATION • 636 South Main Street • Grapevine, Texas 76051 Phone 817/410-3556 - Fax 817/410-3038 CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS APPLICATION Date 2/1 /2024 Property Owner Name, Address & Phone Number Grant & Amy Kirchhoff 324 Ruth St. Grapevine, TX 7 051 Phone: 972-322-2415 Mobile: 214-668-1072 Email: Property Address (include any suite number) 324 Ruth St rapevine, Tenant Name/Occupancy/Use Request/Description of Work to Be Done Number --kc A A-IIZ Applicant Name, Address & Phone Number Same as Owner Phone: Mobile Email: Legal Description Block 6 Lot Subdivision DE Box Install windows for existing house and new additions. Pella Reserve, Traditional - metal clad, Pine, painted white Drawings/Sketches Attached Photographs Attached d,-'Yes o No Material Sample(s)Attached (please list dr2'urrent o Historic Pella° Reserve Series, Traditional - metal clad, pine wood window, painted white l hereby certify that this information is correct to the best of my knowledge and that the said work will be done in conformance with all submissions herein set forth, and in compliance with the City of Grapevine's Historic Overlay District Ordinances and Building Codes. APPROVAL OF A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS DOES NOT CONSTITUTE APPROVAL OF OTHER REQUIRED BUILDING PERMITS. /7 Signed x /l�'u-i �v PrintName Amy Kirchhoff Owner or C actor Office Use o,., Approved- Approved with Conditions: Staff HPC (2-Eo, f is ivj o Denied Chair - Mstonc Preservation Commission Building Official THIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT. A SEPARATE BUILDING PERMIT MUST BE FILED AND APPROVE THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT BEFORE STARTING WORK. DELIVER TO: HISTORIC PRESERVATION DEPARTMENT 636 SOUTH MAIN STREET, GRAPEVINE, TEXAS BY RECEIVED FEB 0 51014 OFFICE 817-410-3556 Ub 0- FEB 0 5 2024 By �/ C 2�4 -07 Filter by: 0 Residential O Personal Business 12 Commercial ❑ Mineral Results per pager 10 Account, Owner, Address Search * 00252239 (Residential) 9324 RUTH ST, GRAPEVINE Property Type: Residential Legal Description: BOX, D E ADDITION Block 6 Lot 4 AIN:-3150---- 6---4 ` State Code: A Year Built: 1950 Agent of Authority: No Agent on record. FO Interactive Map Site Number: 00252239 Site Name: BOX, D E ADDITION-6-4 Site Class:A1 - Residential - Single Family Number of Parcels: 1 Building SQFt: 1,074 Percentage Complete: 100% Land Sqft: 12,671 Land Acres: 0.2908 Pool: FN..e Property Value Geolocation Taxing Units Ownership Exemptions Documents Current Ownership Name: KIRCHHOFF GRANT Address:2117 KINGS FOREST LN, FLOWER MOUND, TX75028 Address Recipient: GRANT KIRCHHOFF Name: KIRCHHOFF AMY Address:211�FOREST LN, FLOWER MOUND, TX75028 Address Recipient: AMY KIRCHHOFF Previous Ownership & Transfers Document Number Deeded Owner Document Date Book Page D223197048 KIRCHHOFF AMY;KIRCHHOFF GRANT 11/01/2023 00143640000466 SURIS LYDIA L 05/25/2000 0014364 0000466 00142620000210 FIRST UNITED METH CHURCH GPV 12/29/1999 0014262 0000210 00075310000936 LANCASTER MINNIE LEE 06/10/1983 0007531 0000936 SCHAEDEL CHARLES T 12/31/1900 RECEIVED � FEB 0 5 2024 CV Q\ N U 0) ce) ti Z Q m � 2 N LLLL c d E O O K � zaUiw a a a a to M VJ VJ d d d d fo U) to to c CU a CD O �C O LL E 00 7 O o - C Co COD M CN *0 to x N 30 Co H N :Q a — 00 _ ui >co c 0 a� 0 ca 0 C� aLo(Da � o Cn s co U 0 N w CV m O 06 N = :O N 0 N � th 0 C 00 U)Cn OCL N 0 L N ti C X N N t'. d M V- Z 0 F- M N o c`o td yL E ea ai E Z' ei ei O C E E Z a w� > G a L Z O z >, F- a .. a� C v m a V v y E C d` G E V b 'Ile O O 3 OF L O 7` Cy O {6 as H 'A O U a C () O m N U N L d 00 t CV •� � � O CEO M N y E C w E: C Y z O a •� d Q as ft �. L C 0) L d L n' .0 O 0)— S = = _ 0 m� -iU)L)0 0 00 C o N co m o CD co I- 2� CO o W_ *_ i N m0 to O 5 _ C = N C r__ y E V L G1 0 C0 .J cn X C p 0 N c a: a) E *k m z to a 0 CC Co aiEo Y a a E z d d fq a. Q c° Z A— d :_ Z 0 w a E 0 E O O E O X R C y N U) a L o W z 0 o d o mC a a -S?O a U TO m o w U m m O LL V d � Q c 6. a a0 CC d O E L UN-0 CD `• 69 = O N U W 0)a7 j U � V) Z U CDc m m 0� O CC, -0 p1 U LU a3 E O a d :2r0� �" `m E mtiai zCs -� avc0, o Zz z C) v w Q N y > N ��� a7 0wCQk WOO m ns ��,, U W W > f- a Q r o r' ao ni W Q 4cL F-G LMc ON m �4LO W �G �O u' zLO O =O cU MH U O m Zcn�Oio Z c _� cu rn ai zz 0 d C) 'O W .0 QO C.c O Ov ti m a U CU lotio C_ C7 00 U O M (L> Q =` X d m0 �L y �6Z O}N r0-. X Jp a)� W M N M 7� > M E N O ins M.OJ C _U p=Z C� N y'U a-)NWZ E 0) 3 y OZ U a O �, - C O J N Z C7 0ov C_ = Q N Q O m 0 c � U on v N_ -@O Q wCDLo aa) or `. 0 01 C7 y C o y X U) E m O c W LL 0 r-: ~ N J Jro (D c p U 0' 8 O v ° api JtiO��LL m -Oc p L0 W U)®� > N,9 aS -00 a W a inaL_m__ n N° a)<ULL a7 E Z C 0 O N O C C x _ LL� •E d O� c O M a) U d `LLD_ 2.2 01 N 0 2 C j O. E U 00 O p •o � p .. @ a O C N c orn U) C C U Z C 'C isp U d C 2 m 0 J O) a) ELn pE `o a; of 04 E m'w °s H� m rnccli aE d ALL LUIU) x cMa�r'C7�� v # f` cM a 04 v X U o v O .p W N w V C iF O C J ry U C -o a' a C ac a3i '> O N rn C O J .- w o� w CV CD (D M 00 a Z N N CD co N a E Z N O LFI i7 m d co a O LL ZN 0 E R CD > L @ > L LL Z o = Li LL z o .� CD a J a d N a= J N N `� L m y Q. a ¢ � N L f0 d .Q CY � `m .20 U o U cn 20 @ p U @ LU to C1 N O ;� N W 0 o ti W O U GS U �- (7 Ln @ N c a- D ` Z 3 LL � u.L Q d 0 c , C` G c' _ 'O UM d E � co ow � pz M c �O(n 3 �OUN N 0w W S y •p L j @� " _ a¢ Q W Z= Z z u)) :o W �Z.cOF- m -0 <0W MZ � y CL d c @ '�— -) OOWO�� -0, 3w c @ ui "�dOamW,c— � ww0 O m @ ac ate) Eoo a t-am o m ¢ UU �`( >v 0c EE 0 W W ?, Q a V o ? 0 ZO d m w a V O Z _ U) LL pV.O '0 W M 00 <n LL U Z �V O 'O N �U CDN 0) @ o~� O N O ?> 0UC c Q D 0) U ~ : :° Q D 0) — U) L 2 Op N W p O L 2 FO N W W � M:O c U MH QN V) N U) U) 0) _ y M:O MH Qdtn c U NCO rn rn O 0)Z ZC0 c -oO.- Ln Qj � N +-• O °) ?�-0O Z cr t(j 7 ON a�� C C O W0 �@ °) C�yN �`r0 °" O NQ w Oi m - 20- 0c-0UW ma W 2EL Ul) O c cn: M@ m-cO Ln U C fM @ m.Z O i< C)0 aN X X d C)O �} 0>N> 2 LQ y �pZ JO jq� W LO N Z JO �p> W L[� M > Cl)7 07= > 0) UM 0 L� > M> 07= � 0 V Cl) O N LO CCy yW Z C cu (n 0 OZF- d Cl) aN yWZ OZHN (n U 0A LL O y M TO W c = >%d co0-- Jc�CC Z !O=2 @Qr L '2 OO N W @U) N 0 �wmII ' @N y U MO)Ln _DL @ N)MC N NOLn d= � @ fA @ N a U C yOcW U UON@ LLJ N (I ?c O) CN W LL N AN cX O fO aj _ J�C(n0 0 30 0fy 00 n- - LL tv m 'OUO J 3 2w00� c O LL _G -6L N 7 N (D LO ((n �E, J@ @ ®LLOE L N 7 N J@ d •- N LLJ a) � �cn cjd O >Ln T: c�c N� owOW cOW >Ln N- C a- N -a O O d L m LL � 7 C� NN CL cc LL `N0CpW a 0 0) O 2 s LLJ O 0 U 7LL _ 7 x yO ON E O Ec � U.LL l0 a) wd N 7Nx N0 COO N U. C 0 O 5 �OO M E @ac GNN U O O M 0 cQ ON E radNrnOo N=ONi O C NOw<cC(D-: Oc00fUCcVc NOvcZ� C ®aGi> -U - EnCE -UU IL m C O) a)NN N` po c ELLn EO m@ O Ln a) M O U X N V Qi M d K (0 W cy�2 N t) d@ N CfAC�N��2 d d lN0 d 'C cN(92 Ctl)dC CD d �LL� a �u-0 W Ncj W > o — o W cat u m W LL M c7 # 4k C N to d N x X _m c is Lj co i+ w cv) J LU O C J FLU O C m U- C m LL C N C N CL C > > c 7 J w J CCV w o W > o �CV r, CO U m G) 00 CV S CV CO Cl) a) a E 7 z `m a L: V CV M :1E m I cv m ai E m Z U N O rail VN a a w ZZ a) a O .0 d a) a a a CY m Q U O U m o U- t� v U 0 a o) Z C V CN q x u1 E U co a) U a c N m E O d LL v CD C) c o ca =o � Qo �C r` c `- - N Z Z i0 cIj �rn rn LL 0) Q0 O (L v U N f- a7 x (� q 0 r a) O) C; E n x ti r J maw �z N C co C) a LL U N W O } a) 4.7 f0 � 3U_�aco M d --a C 0 04 NLC m �~ O Z'II mm Na c L .0 d O C LL a) fA ail a) a) _ N J lC fn �fn� vR�v.0 N L U O R '2 (D w aa))Uii�� 'a a m m O w > d� a x mdLL N o CO rnC7LL ai LL (n f6 J N U N M C N 0 7 E a 2.2 12 G1 05 LO O S 'E �' O- 2 y ail vX m LLaa- `-°U ECU d �� E o- .. m c 0 oc oa Bo- - a) N � V 0 C 0 C U Z ��co rn�= LU cc = mom cCL a) ® CO y Q 1 N O O) d Q E Z M r- cc C c`� o d 4-:LLO W CfAU' " CLX w L2 Y a c14 l� O Z x �p W x W Cl O J F- O Y Ui a a) > J LO N V o L- o a K w L x M N x LL d t N cc co L d CD a m c J ems) a a) N Y a) N � O LL a) a Q a m Q U ?' m a U � o L- LO C7 0 d N C x U x w w y L ail E U � a) U a C a) a3 '0 4) E O Q O LL a m C O N z Ob in Q `. LO ,n7U _- Z iD C� 1 j •= CD cC) m0 E c N a) d w 0 } d x c o-1cfaw J > 0 O CO p c = Z ca O y Z M 'O U cn O 3: d aciU��n00 M 3 - N - aN � L j ail �c C/) cc L, 11 -O 'O -2 O .0 a O d C N a U m CL Cw� m�@LL d co U� �U)w V V c a) 'o�Lv a�iptiO-5E -0 WE00>>ai°om maaNmarnC��ai fA v1 'C io Z E c c C O L O C C E O fn a) �X'a liLL 0 at7 N C O )0 a) U) � a y L)E U D N E C O acod@ Z �° N K N vC O O C fn 00 U C a 0a ELonJ S E 0,E d y C L in o m d O. O �LL`8w5U) CL m(93� Y � a N CO Z Q 0 c ZLL C�Z O Z J 2 to w mUJ UQ. QIX �O 4' N co co rn 00 r` (D E Z d 0 CY ,a7 V LQ tmt ? a L acc a o a :� a w w a O 0 a '6 m a CD (D a aa) a 0. 0 U @ <j 9 CO co o W Z co 0 L V oo LO LL 0 W ZO d v c ` � a d o a c aZ ( > O> CL E �' �' E m O�ii m W Zd U x ;: U X �rLto O W QQ LL m E @ ° Q[9LLlar1 M z U U o 00UJo— a oJC m U � � f-N W p CO �CL C E E (n vv aW` ¢oC �- F- F OLL a 0 o p (DLi d LL O -° a .° U a U ca m m o ° C)c v o c Qc6 N Qao rM Cp LM W 2 L9 = rna cA c — `n ZZ a? ZZ ip C W N� Q =' clj� a)O� Q p 0 O Q p 0 O a Q a •- Q N cn U l m~ @ U of N H m X Uv ca ° �( Uv m5 d N �o � m eh mC, a`> _ X _ >L 6Joi5 W CV L NJN�LL N c�'zo -2Z ai CO .° O ca)r=Z W— Z > N N K m• — (L `- U > LL U N W o Z� a . M c No--' `- @ c 3U�N,a �+ �— O_Ur �— 0Q aN N � c J c o rn c c J= O m Q 'II /iW m C C (n CC LO O vi CmNZU; Vl (D NLn'O U�+ 0a@dLN a N cC L NO C-LL (D CC,LL aII)N > ca sm co lC Ufn �tnp �av c� UN o(np 2Ofv c �, C -pL m 0 mares a) C �L m O marLL a) w a)U) E .' mo �wOw� > ai °° .� mo cwc0w� > a)-°o 0 c m -- a -- tLp maalloprnc7�ai mnm�n600rnC�u �n _m J a) U Cn m J• a) U tnN r W HU Ev ° c ~ �� y HO EZo o m C1 _C p d N a+ m d L O C •C 0 L Y N �+ m mM LLa•Ow mU EU mX mu'LL 7.Ow mV m N d N N E 2.5 a N M `, a m C= U 0 d d � a7 7 0 m Z C "° N ox N 0 O- 0 7 V m Z C N K N C V O 10 C tC0 U~— C x N C V O C 0 C U F- — C ® tLL9� W p`%a �Lfp�`•--I C E ® LLN_ ` I C cc CT CO CD N d 2. O m` O Ln S E C . N C. a yo,O. N d x C m@ a7 f0 �• a N d N A y X R 10 •� l`6 U a U. W_U)0(L c9�a d �LL0LU s(0t7a�C9?�� v # M # C? Y CN a N N d N --:r X X 0 j o v o O o a� c a X cn m 1 NCc iOs a Cl) WW W J O ----- 3 L.L L NC n CCL Q O O V L JY J Ll � J Ix M W N _> C=) C=l W c I nZ w L V N V O c I- _O` a N d a C0 a 0 ' CND 69 0 > L z ^, CF) � K W .�@. =y N d K W 0 'y Z a= a r d v N a m J 4) .- o d d a w a E r v 5 a "' �, 20 a 76 o m U m 0 U m v oU O Ln m O V N LO C 2 O Ln U N d LL C .O CO EN _ d E � _ U M as w W W CN _ N E m _@Z1.W Q E 0Z I LL Um ' c w 'b 0� m Lu M @4) E O N O-9 Q¢ LU N O E q o J�'U @m aU pl J LuL o I.- wN LL -o o U- Nwo Z a m z o v y O N -o Q_ m J U a co c 'a 0 o� r_- VFW- p O �0 ° = °' rno T ¢� r° C @ E tnW pp a Q� LM 00 L 9NO 0U Cy U fU M F- Iz tn N C r Z Z to C U N to •@• c Z r ca 7 O - J r 0 yrn .2 7 Z J r d Q (D w00- r rn C rn my E m a d v Q Na.2 rnL) NIr- N O Ua W x m @ 0a @(D C ) m o 0 c d@ N t0 N M_ �: rL >L Zp JNa W >>L O L6 y @Z J0 cM� m7 d p U W 0 _ O r U y w O Z d .. r 3U�vai�l C y U N y W Z O Z H @ @ 3� U�� N nin _� a J O J C h V i � W. N C I I o z � 't 1 N Z d O= W rn Z I I t c�a9 daoLo o� CO U'a'° CD N Naomi N '0 oL O c� -0L C NU0LL N J c� �O m0LL LC N � @ U W @cc -mE N � 6 2�+V@ Un �fn0 Of V C N CC CU O -i a) J O U�(Mp C N 0 LL N �a,dUtLpr�E = O C: -� L N O N J@ a 0 vmya>U g)LpN �E E - 'C a�w0w>>m°oa� -_ '' -@OCq--.0WU y>>to -00� Z R cco2 d 75 d a N O C 01 LL lL @ d a N O O U C@ u0- !L ~ N tot @J CUB U U` @ Z nC/7 @J d NQ C U U7 0 1C z U C@ .(U O to C tl! W L d' O C. 7 E 'O rn 0@ .. X C _N N @ 7 N O C '- T O E 'o C f1 m IOLLU. -0 @U Z 6 d rLL� 3 -1c,EU 202r CMEO d Z� LA Q�a4CO@ •� C O L Crnm�N wR md K O C o N-` NU 0d O C mo C CUOCcV 0 O CO CU E LOJE E @N 0 Q 0 _�Ol N`R E'05 o a2 N)0 E p 4% d M M d x (D A@ di N 2 M N rLL0' W CU) IL U' �Q Q1 d Cl) A m X 0 @@ V G1 •C i-LE0LU CfAU' 2 CC/1a�MC7?�Q 2 U c O _ v Cl) � Cl) in a N a N 0 x x U o v C? O v AD C 0Cl) i e E X — c2 OlO X EO O 10 01 C_ fT] J H J Q (7 U- C 3 Oa 11 _.' 3CL o V5 xi d *� , ��6b �" > r cm d ) > s cm O U C J 0 C J LO 3 o .� W N C= N Q W C%? V m W LLJ = LL- co z Oz I- w 2� Zo cV 2 O N M co (D E Z `m _0 W d o a)' 0 W �, C= a00 > W x EA 'y p x d9 u Cz m w O z a w w—, o W LU CL L as � N o � N .a N 7 a O CO, d (0 a mCY 0o U y Z o 5 U r o O U O m m u5 (�) @ d N LL o d .v w m C� (L c to Z z d co > .0 0. � 4. .0 F �. w 02 Cl) y•- o 0. — w y m w 5 �-o mW - w ZO a) c a c v o a¢uQiQy �z z? O E a EO (D ° c c � U-LL -Jp� oo��'N �a OH 3 t m E a) E 3 0 �-_� W a �� �tl3 fl CD D Z Q O LZ O� LL 'O LAN L10 "O Q'Q Zqj- Oo CO c = U c W a 0 U c> ��C) iD Cl 1O~ 2 U z0 cn d Z(D (n O ON NBO w M OVN 0o 27c MIU— n j In °'OU Q O� r� to y y U N U) (n N ' rn Z io c m Z 01 O wco ma d0� v X UJ EC-T Da m v Q =Q p�� m 3 a :?w E Q N m _c spa U ma ' E v�i•oo U� F d a NUS F- C _C ,� N Q E c xd W3 O}� �L OZ LL @ N w0} 9? Ui Ln N JO m M� 3J N >0 V w O '0 .6 OJV a> J>� W 0 O U N� T Z K .n -p p V E �•�- Z 'D N V � N (Oi)Z OZ~_ 6L NNZ = -0 COONc� 3 a M•Zp- Q ( N c U) �II y 8'p~w wV) i>IN1p . 0) C (i -O a) � U) N (0 N 'IT �0) 6 U m Gi L 02 y W W (OD a7 N U m Cl)Y CL cW �o cW 3 t6 n LL y J �_ LL"OLW o c) m� 3 m LL O R J(/)�� JJ p ��� vi c a) R NU)'O_j U� uS c d _ O 'O t O 'O N --� al d 0 72 rn pe0 LL0M LL a) � E C O L 'O (o a_ m O� vn m W p LL O m E 3 a �Oa� ac)p>ao �o = '� ac yam(' O' > om 'O c N a ma�a�Eo cma) tiJ W a a. LL cv f6 y `ma E0m ` es- o d LL W (n H O- N D N Q C y O) U Cp N C FCL w N y 0, U C ' N C E� e_ x - C? p C N N w as W a) 0 0) C C E� O A ii C p 2 m N L C> LL O (a d (o E U. d 0 O O f` C cc a M` ai E U X• O LLN m =' O C> a) E E U d O) O `_ m Q C rn O O c O N O C n c N C VoNc C1 4) M e_ ` L_` cu N U C O CU Cc R �� apM— `V N EV OC C E w O C ILL)0c OZO N_ E O CCrn EO M�C o 0- E d X O`O�(o m �U2 CL d mN � 1LUW d d(D d���U `��d LL(DLu Qf0 O 0a) v v h (o ch # C?# C. N oD O. N 1� X X `o v o v M C •Q ca U L Z O VO »X( Z O0Z Cl) (C_ Cy Lj- p) _.. ..._..... _ _..._, .w_ LL y nb4 3 `� „j.e 3 Oa 7t a) > L 4t _D t c C J (�O 7 w C J O- w a N 2 co Cl) 0) E Z N ru .'O. Q' N Cl) L: co d 00 m 0) E co z U N O d 0�, W CV > o MO v 00 W IL a CL C%Z U co� ;L m W W W Z a.� = R a lL Z o= W J 0.9 _N J a d C N L ``' f0 y 75 " D_ Q L 1d f0 CrD p_ Cy in OCY `m .20 Q O ' m U o`m -o m w ° i�l z O �U ui LL 0) p _m LoUZ W LL O F- Z ` n d dNQw c^ ED 0 Uo 3 cu LL E Y UL mw z c `°>ci� dN �Z Z? c Urn .0 E rn"c U�LLLL� QJ¢a LLJ ~ OH a O cdic f m =a �c00 m 4)a>- w� nw a) a' m o0 c. E d °O t N U) 7 c d `oOU fn =w w Q� O LL ° m m aU W rn Q° aUcA Z U Z pN -° NZ LLa0 �vc� 'O 0j .O > O 00� Mo (6 (� V C)N N M 00~.0 -p —° 00 0 O N y - 00 3 2 ao p N LIJ 00 m C 2 O M I— f0 to C O co H Q a) I` to C U Z c N fn _ �_0 (n w U N fn cn °lam 7 o c —m w00 •C O) O C J C �_Lo 4Szz w W O t E'O 0'°? t p lNOm 0.0= Q N3 dm— co w E Q N3 d�c i` co c (7 oil v m ~ C) Ci s_ 0) U� oa~ M x OJ �> O Omit- 0) X x zc N ❑cI O} o2 N O "' Lq _ L> cn f9 Z L6 J O— w Ln ... 3 p L cn Z x W) > M> 0) >p U Z 4i Mai j0 OI >0) dO O C `y @wZ OZH N_ Lo v NLLZ pZ~j•o N 0j N _ C 0) ' = LL'a C 0 J N D c. Z C U l] y 02�� Q N = LL� O w y c cZ 3 w C U t] O V a000 2�� mQ� CD @"O n."O N y�0 V) if OL 0--6J d OHO m.� OL C U 0) 2 'O C j N 0 N 0 C i U@ f_N, OJ N T cn W M 01 o)'O U m V) > C L C 0) y X�� 0 O (n O C W 0) o@ LL N N J Vi Z C >t> � U Y X �D > W U U) 0 c w LL O ~ J N .0 0J O U um c 0 LN J N O J C' N O U of co C d O -c d 3 N powrnN�' J d 0 0 @L oN LL 0) 3E C O _ o',w00Z` JcuCD ®LL0m �E Lo = ccc0LU CD acid >CD --°o = 1° �.cw0 a� ui Q)M m 0) > cv cu a�30 w^in m J n �cmy y C �a R L a �a�'tiEo w�cn LL_mH 0 �'E'erm=oa �0LL o .. C X C y y (,� � U) amiQ 13f0 z 0 'O C N C ~ C X N L U F, U) —� o aO1i O <0 Z E E C C 0 LL O 3 _`_ C C N m_ E C "O d 'C C W m a)Ci c U) 3 = N C C U. 3 'p C £ 'O C 0@ d'E y' co a f0 3 M 0) 0i �. LLL Ci d In LL LL O O f0 �. 0) E U 67 Lo E 0) .0 o C 3 — E m m = �p O) to a 0 0 o E .0 f`0 C 3 a U E U N y G> c_ , o .. p.c o m V% aiw o C 5O a) Q 0 co m`U c� C O C in N c C U N d cM o .. Co a� O_ p m � 4) N N C° O C u7 N 0) CD Zw m � � � C C.! H � ® N U 0 0_ C u M C .o l6 0) y O ELo"Z c E _ c.i R C 0) Ln R `PULL i`a a -N J C) N ELo E E u�i oa c i .cc 4)� p M A U ® R C d dr N °) c 0 IL ad+ 10 e-LL0w CU)Cox c0 a.�Mi�32' a M •• � d K C rnl0 10 .d. LLt9w_ .-c�x cmIL V 0i R U c9 �2' Iq a'N O # v C? , n ch Q Y V C # LLIC. N 1� X = O. N X LLJ Q c _ N X CO O .i0 CO VW J W O ch C J W W K� O M C O W C O U_ C N c > > J r J 000 0 Al F" i7 O W C—) O `" ` ri d C EA > L N > CC1 N Lu w z o= a W K 0 m W a Z 0EL a J O C d L co O_ L f0 a w m Ci U 20 a Cl in O �, a `° m c � a� Ucao, 0 UMa) o p (n U ii y 0 `n U m ti 0 M m (D LO V � U Lo •r N @ a� o L � �� o c dLo 3 ci 0 IL 06 `m m o E UM E v_ 1 7E UNa aci a) ER = N "L" X 0) to J U2 al (n � 0 X N .- W �' Z M:(1) .0 O W 0 C a) -+ A a O C ,+L- oUJA f m N U cL U14=)W Piz� `L m 0p 0• 0 0) CD tt � z z? E m a`6i o 5 av�° o 0Ww M1-- U0 0 ti o�Nmo m Q� UJ 0 mw Zai oN E m V O T C C C W F' (L •O .V p U 3 C ..._O. y MO� U ? 0X .,0_, p>j N-L f9 LO N W �'~Q LLOJ ZO a 0 —C O)C �� 0 L 2 ON co 2 O MF- O'yl� n U = O NU a)n- N C Ln U N cn N 0) cn U N (n y O) Z �' Z .- O p cfl lv O 0) z p co ma ao o° �� ..�+ o n ao o m°) Q ap a ��o� E Q0 a) c0v n, E N O U j 7 N O U�� m c eo °a m•o ma N CD X �)0 �� oN X x a> co oCi }�>=> X Lq �L y �Z Jp �� W LO L y @Z JO d> W LCi M O) " U M O r c7 O) " > O a) M O M 'n m.o= c 0 �z�N d M LO Co°of c 0 �Z o=Z C aj�y(nWZ Cl nod ai5a U)LLJZ oZC: c 0 Mtn am >,(D aOi' ac 2 c� 3m >U� a)var) = a 0 c 0J a C002 ma- = a-0 c 0� (Ni) c05 0 maw C a) 0= "p11 Z O F-' C U-a-S a) y Noi� E:� o� CJ U�aa y y_ -c04 - Cl os '17 G (!) O G W N a7 co -o L .0 Cc CD (n C W co N c y X f0>+(0 y o a) O 0�1--_ NJ Vi Xm3�0 d (Y,) y @N� NJ i0 J�mUJO J o c) c �vtn0� o — = () l a) J W a .-- u- a) L a) 7 (D -J m a LL a) a � EOW� aci> >cri (D `� c60 �4c-OW� aa))� >cli aS° al 'O a cmd c m M CL 0 CM(D —° W 0) N O a 0 o N 2(5U- U lL`n-aa NJ O w o.°)m(7LL aai H O N O C y 7 E •O C 0@ ~ X C N N U�, 7 E 'O C O Gs _ c � m o- d U) — m N O C' (; 0 ca _ — LL 7 C a) 0 0 7 m a) d 2 :7 LL C 3 C O C O 10 N m Lo E a) o o m 0 o U E U 4) R LL a m o o c a U E U C> rnM E `o .. m a� rn 00 0 0 0 Cs prnch E C ` @ a� a)—,o 0 `p O y ll.N C U 0 a C O U7 C 02 C U C fA N C V O C V71 (n C C U Z= 'C ® LO d �,`o oa ``e m E ELo `E ® �N 10 oVa c A d E�UJ CD E M a) K r R !� 10 a) V a) O a) 0-0 M d K Iy0 l0 a) C> d E d vLL0 W ctnC72 cWIL C,( �� d �LLC� W 5(AC72 Cfgd�U' 3� v it j ch t` M Y rn Y (n a. N cc) d N Cl) X X 0 _r m 0 .i0 UW Cl)0N Uj W _ U_ O LL O C 0 LL .. O C J LL J LL O LL C p LL C C 0- ; m a ft d > cm d) r� n�1 > cm C Lo 3 C 7 J co J rn 0 o� N CD Co m 00 r` N .a E m Z d 0 C1 N S 04 w M a`) E Z O L a ID C1 °D •� rn a a K " • CA W Z o �' .-. o y 'm m a x 0 Z a- a J N C (- J Nf _N N N a) L f6 N 0. N 75 d m 5 UO (n ) 2O y�Qcoam `@a)-o _ E Qo O U.)U a _ o O LO ci oCC!i tald+ aN'NO m co ao2 O o w• N Uo a O m m UoZ Nt:p U XyC: `„ ' two CD co _ Q uW U_ c �� c� a'E I w> a o,o L) U cL a m0IV '•�_• N E -,jaZE`OT NN N O E va� -0o0-a o o 03E 0)NNo maJa U U J a p W O o oU E Nov N oU �� UN a c > o�� aooN �.� otCL � �0 Z° rn0 y �~ ° 0) y ANU O_ C p CO a) Q O Q co ==. O ON LM L O` �pN 7 70o NU aa) N rnrnao °'c NU a>22n Q O MH y N =�N x 0 MH j U N Cl) O U N Cn d 0 0 0 N Cn Z -7.20 O IT Z _ O - m c Z COU Z c IL ZO N J J—Cn N>> U N W CC) a Co p a o N W 00 O @>> V 01 rn o a o N m rn a aCD � y w 2Np o m 06 c�a m ma matiu. N W 2i MO }x w Ol0 N CO �'j2 H H y C e- >> 3 0 H N j C r _� C p i '. 04 >> N N jC = co C)JZ >Cn NN _ ' 5>N coL c NZ JO N> E E W _ 7 N O £-. f� �� �O _ >� NN Ip t0 p a OJ U x c°a cMZ J CY Ex1LLZ N' L N Z_ C > N> �_ (0 •� N O V O C C CCco 15 Ca c Z O N> .- @ .N.. W O y@ d � W Z O Z N O O N �Cn a� >U 8— Cl) S � 3U c cc) 3a �U� NN>> aco Co w m Z Q O� p � c W m J T_ p W m Z J m O ff° °o c rn rna 04 Ufa otn ti Now y Eg ��a ° dr�� ()-CL p d m mpjLO aa) �'c c 6-om W ° No c W @ a�•ta co c Z,-oLa cR co in ° <no ccrnm" c c ch X c�c: 3 0 o.@�i— .v � m d x m m U a`) co lC JU NUJ J 30 v(YLO UU �U° V� JU �U°J O i��oo �?�'�o.c d C a L NO N J fa a N N a L N 7 N a -� L N 7 d J Ca a N c c LL N .tetaH iINCnnc7 Nx�N C1d°6LLVXp a0 0Z, — °) w N.a3®vLL°O(n -Q �CiOW=m m> •A_ cr alloaD0a2M.2-�> -0.-=Ow>cocD -0(ammc�2 O m°Cm .0 QUJoUam� o� o ��LL aaLa)O) J> U O Q � D Z N C C � 0°'y 0�yUx c ❑ U) E N p E: of aN 'E y `01ir Ocd� ca aSVNx=Oa =__7LLLLa C 2,R a Du1 N aCO UO aM£ Ecn p O. Cm 0_ . ZdU O_U O O pZcoNC� O(a VcCr N0_c5ON0)w � = u Swa5O a'N , UNN~=UV WU oV d C co Cc O(iUlac 0A—m dC mihy E07NN2 Ld2Ecn E Eo0m Ln NV UN �M 0= M dX1d �� A C1 A ddo p„ LL7w5m0c7x GNa�05N7cjUwnC2 47U.NCLqLLDfC1>>7 c'M Y � 1 CA CL N LO X `o d' c `;' 0 O L U z_ ` E J > O` C J LL E J IIlA3 7 0 W N ` O CV W o V m W 1.1 w LL_ z oz Uo W Z z LU Ua Z U N 2 04 co M m .n E 7 Z m r u 6) 4E 7 N co ca a C2 CO a) E co Z U d 'O d W C=l _O IL a o a 0 — o P ._ L w Z Z a W LU a- a= J N C J N C a) L w @ O a L w f0 N p. a a Ci r U) O cn O `m @ U m `m @ Z U m O co LU p �U m Zp z JLd � m m aC O W W Q CN O M d"O a.>m0'n2C w a_ cu OW CsL co m N� OI fwCi� W dCi Q N "'h'z �W c U m c U E CD C'@i an W V OF - a O c - @m> a O E - @a) oa OO�Onj�O ._ w M rz m 0000 a�, `Va ¢ pJ F-Wa r'C� Q UW E y 0 d y E y a�Ui 3 �- ai �W p 1Q- O J a v �o _ J a v g w 0 LL O O Z _ (o ON'O Q O LZ _- LL ON'O a� V d U p(D COQ� y.@.. Q_ _ Z� N L O C N W O 2 O W :3 S O MH Q'a) NCn wO Q O MH Qa) tfJ NCo VIOL-_ OU Z C J Ln a) cn _@ C J — ul C C oCo la W 00 N ao °o ff U' C ma W CO N ,0 O1 -C) 0-�v a- QO�O ° da E U) 0 va oa Ua 3 - (n-3oo oLL �L w �Z JO ffi VI OZ JO �6 E W i0 UM > M> CnJ i0 U_M C. O Z ai l7 @O Z �p_ .Z N yU�VWZ C 3-00CD!a O>w3: aUV) VZ O N CZ �(n S M0J C, a� NC W OU) 12 Z� @W V C _ Cn GOU 2 @T 'O wOIn 2-- /)N � (nc2.0 w(IDI � CT N �, •@O .0 a) X cc >� N U In C:) C W N m a~ �' � L � W K N� �� V � O C W E - @ N 'O J J �Ln O UaO� J NJJ O U3.2 D00 C d 0 c -p L W 7 a) o d m 0C 0) J@ a @LLpm� L N -O _N o m.N ol2]E` C) J@ a C LL a) @LL0M (o j E _ .a cr cM(D C: >(riai� ca �m -- I aCip>(riaLO i�Da`I 11 cc cca aN J a y o 020Lua N(Dayo �LLW Q .(. .. �i U f0 W Z x N (,� u) t0 Z EO p C C1 7 N C C C T 7 C? p CT a E C w O C y <a N O C. �, 7 C p O E 'O C_ U O 0 = LL C a1 @ '� L` a y 0 d O C O 2 0 W CL (..) C 0@ is _N LL 3 C d 0 W LL a 0 0 m C CL U LL E U) Lo cM @ a� C= al 6- 0OZ a to c � p � .. m aC 7 U old �Oz� N CU V CO C JN 12 U N CUU CO C ® CA @ IC6U_N U-) IL ma�EECD nv-gym A a7J C7 Q) o`oa m2EEnv-SSE ul E d w @ tC m 0cli N E w 0-0 �C m 0 � M 01 w .. 0 K ''' 1a R M, i N m U d '-' O z M Cad. d w a ` 0 x w as A@ 4) � � E U QI ,� O •� �` U IL �LL� W CyU= CVid�N:7NLLC7 W CNr�2 CVid �N:7�?�� C? Y a N LO Cn X v I C? O X t0 W r 0 X MR E � � � o U- U- E d I 0 o f d h� > J O o a: M N Cfl /b co rn NF- L: E Z a? 0 3 C1 N S p CV to M a`) E 3 Z A 0 CN N M fC Q- (Q .c m ai E cv Z U 0 0 W H V V N > CV d d M p (L p W 6*2 @ 'a 69 > L @ LLJ V m Lu W z° a° a)am LU z a = a a m o a m v J N C d J a) • ? L f0 y CU a m n CY U) O 0 Q Ci � U) S Oco N Q a� rd+ V3 N TV m wo � 0V) L.m_. .aaa)=Ti Xao '2 L, '2�pU a)Om mW q- L Ln co N d NaM o m m L:)U 0 CC C l 'O Cc, Oa N E a UNOam U X Sm 2 _ wc) c V 8 a m US O O mN- Z a v , O cd' a 3 m 3 a EOn_ i cA Oz a E ° > C`mn 0)O aj cO (? _� `0acn a�mo U- L) w¢ ma)o o a U LL Al r� n x via o a U u Li z o v m -o iL o z O z o a m 'o N O N E m 1- f� LL ai o N E m •p U p C w Z _Zz U co c d S U N Cn W �� CL J� O Qp y RV4ao p N ui W W Q m Q O Op O) 2 O N 1T 12 � w !- 0. _c 2 N 2 c 2 0 M H N d In W LAI Q fl' 2 0 M H y In 3 t QJ�(mn U p Z to ix Z LL O O) ZJ -�7 �atz.0 O Zc a0Noa wa)o) a ao O 0v CeO- 10 pm'C>E QO pmc E Q w3 0.iop'c Q 1n3 dip 1n o U � :3 m o L) uf ma and L ma m M 5c Cl) a^ 00 o_ �� in 5.9 r M '5- `g c 0_ LQ 7L N �Z Jp a)2iw Lt'! `-L rn �Z JO d W N r)�i mr� >oENz N M� �N� >pE z 11i @ J C V O lO a Q J C U N O ai��ennWZ C) T) a; cm,�, nwZ 1 Z- m a 3 C 0 y p N a� a U p NT��� p Oa- ccJpJ1w c=QzO=zO mW n w n m 72 C, CT o da V) p N 0) aa d M d fU) Co N m m O 0) co �O COWNm N CLGF- �C W LL au ) 3x .2m Lf i X m:Bao a) m L!) vi J J�fApLL O U�IOn� cr J� m0pLL O Uu0i d _ -p L N 3 a) J m a 1O r' LL a) _ -p L a) 3 N J M d 1n V- a) O ° y v� rn�Z ®LLp�� �E O _ d m I �LL.0N 3 E m o fw0w� mp >� ai oo = m -mo �4c--OwC? cp m� O a� N aiw nc LLJ clmLL o m o a °OwCmLL°mmw a) Q,U) Qa cmi X w yC� co) .2 C@ x y HO 0 mZ C co LL C a p 0 O c 3 m am) G� _- - U- C 3 p C a) O c 1100 0 L.2 M LLa oo m N �N 2a c cN£� pmyON E `my rndu .. M ac O = CD zo C V C n f/l C C U E C d fn N C O O c rn U) c 12U m O C C -L mcd -mo -,rno LO -VUmc �a m CD CD M� ova 1`a m E1nV E E MN �o `o �a m m E�Uz E ® N m a1 k m m a) 0 d� O •C � N ® N R d K d U) 1�y0 t�9 y V a, m O .` l`0 cL U p. �1�(9w5�n(9x cmaE�c93� a :-ac9Lu U) x ctna��t93� H M M Y LO U In d N Cl) m a N chi U_ x U X c Q Q t O w X O w x 0 w N (7 w N J Q O` E- J Q O C (7 J LL C (7 J LL C 1 3 CL - -- -- a) CL C Lo > 7 G O > 7 J J 0 Colors -#�-c -AZ4-o7 Wood Types Wood species for complementing your project's interior. Pine Prefinished Pine Interior om in e r finishes, unfinished or primed and ready -to -paint are also available. Colors LWhlt* Bright White Linen White Natural Stain GoldenOak EariyAmerican Provincial Stain DarkMahogany Stain Staln Stain Red Mahogany Espresso Stain Charcoal Stain Black Stain Stain Aluminum -Clad Our low -maintenance EnduraClad' exterior finish resists fading. Take durability one step further with EnduraClad Plus which Exterior Colors also resists chalking and corrosion." Black White Bra— Fossil O Custom colors = are also available. Irbil Portoballo Putty Almond Classic White Brick Red Hartford Green Added Peace of Mind Integrated Integrated wireless security sensors maintain aesthetics, streamline security installation and ensure no warranty loss is Security caused by post -installation drilling. Sensors can be monitored via the free Pella' Insynctive' App and are compatible with Sensors major security panel systems.' For more information, go to connectpella.com. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS CITY OF GRAPEVINE RELEAS 4 PURSUA T T C_ 7 DATE ZBY L dEPAkWENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES CONTACT BUILDING INSPECTIONS FOR PERMIT INFORMATION The Best Limited Lifetime Warranty in the Industry lZiMuLtzi41PETIME We know your reputation matters and you stake your reputation on quality, dependable products. That's why we RW have the best limited lifetime warranty in the industry for wood windows and patio doors.z RECEIVED ' Some Pella products maynot meet ENERGY STAR- guide He a sin Canada. Formore information, contact your local Pella sales representative or go toe nergystorgic.ca. ' Based on comparing written limited warranties of leading national wood window and wood patio door brands. See written limited warranty for details, including except 0 C �O'Li� limitations, at pella.comlwarranty. J ' Performance ratingsvary based on product configuration. ' Flush multislide handle is a Pella exclusive design. ° Flush multi -slide handle is not available in Champagne. ° Color—tched to your products interior and exterior color. ' Appearance of exterior grille color may very dependingonthe Low-E insulating glass selection. ''^�'° j�9(�(7 ° EnduraClad Plus protective finish is not available with all colors- See your local Pella sales representative for availability Fno Ilfl �rf ° Requires the lnsynctive App on a smart device, an lnsynctive Bridge and a wireless home router with internet connection. ��V..Jl LLL.��� -.7 © 2023 Pella Corporation. All rights reserved. ASTB2B0323 I W267400 0 5 2024 f rl Kayce Vanderpool From: Grant Kirchhoff <grantkirchhoff@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2024 9:52 AM To: David Klempin Cc: Amy Kirchhoff; Keith Barnes; Kayce Vanderpool Subject: Re: Window Questions RE 324 Ruth Street, D.E. Box Addition Historic District Attachments: BriarPath - 324 Ruth St_17789662 2.pdf *** EXTERNAL EMAIL COMMUNICATION - PLEASE USE CAUTION BEFORE CLICKING LINKS AND/OR OPENING ATTACHMENTS *** David Thank you for the conversation last week and clarifications. Attached is the updated quote/designs from Pella which shows that the majority of the windows will have the full grid pattern. The only windows which will not are the backyard facing windows (Game Room, Kitchen, Master Bedroom). If all is ok, we look forward to the approval for the CA so we can get these ordered to avoid delays. RECEIVED Thank you FEB 2 0 2024 (-'-- Grant On Fri, Feb 9, 2024 at 2:09 PM David Klempin<dklempin @grapevinetexasusa.com> wrote: Dear Amy, On January 81h 2024, our Historic Preservation Assistant replied to your email of January 6th. I am writing to reiterate the response to question number 3. The reply was: A: The dividers in the windows should match what is currently in your house. The six over six is required and approved by the HPC for this house. The elevations approved on #CA23-45 at the July 26, 2023 meeting of the Historic Preservation Commission was for six over six window configuration throughout the entire house for the upper and lower sash. Please see the approved elevations, attached. The windows approved on #CA23-45 are appropriate for your house. We received #CA24-07 on February 5th, 2024 for wood & wood clad Pella Architectural Series windows, white interior and exterior with six over one configuration. Your proposed revised elevation windows are not consistent with the original windows of your house. The goal of the Historic Preservation Commission and the landmark designation is to preserve the historic integrity of original structures. Each structure in the Grapevine Historic Township is unique and its features are to be maintained. If you want to make this change to your house, #CA24-07 must go before the Historic Preservation Commission for consideration. The earliest possible meeting would be March 27, 2024. Staff cannot administratively approve this significant change and would not recommend for it at the March 271h HPC meeting because the change is inconsistent with the windows of the original house. Your proposed wavy glass for the master bathroom windows would be allowable as it would not affect the sash configuration. Your selection of white metal clad wood Pella windows is appropriate for your house, however they should be six over six configuration. Please let me know how you want to proceed. Thank you, Amy, David Klempin Historic Preservation Officer 817 454-4422 cell 5Y1C8 L 'BAItadY89 'IS HVIS M sr� ors w iarwa wAoa iaoe sttc s � N 71WI IV" M o +_ a1N8Q�S98 AdOHB.7lQ1 .a w p xnawnx�o MVHOw TlassflH I s -#-C'}A 2 3 -y5 N o M+....ea +: „o . 6PG[P -11Z SY7Cdi '3NIA8dYN9 l-1 r w. �y -, �• • ia.'m 7r�oa IOU tLze IS H. na tac 1Y1llOG5R -11i1�119 BJti su "OEM � � 9 d ` ti � N Q µ. .,. nd N Y QOII E � rt � J 1a1ssaa! 3w