HomeMy WebLinkAboutCA2017-07 (2)MEMO TO: HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
FROM: DAVID KLEMPIN, HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER
SCOTT WILLIAMS, BUILDING OFFICIAL
RON STOMBAUGH, PLANNER
MEETING DATE: WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 22, 2017
SUBJECT- CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS #CA17-07
DR. W ILLIAM DABNEY LIPSCOMB HOUSE, c.1888, 1910 ADDITION
221 WEST COLLEGE STREET
MILES AND SUZANNE NEWELL, OWNERS
NEAL COOPER, COPPERSTREET HOMES, APPLICANT
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends the Historic Preservation Commission approve with conditions Certificate of
Appropriateness #CA17-07 for the property located at 221 West College Street, legally described as
Block 14, Lot N167.5 of W80 Lot 3, Original Town of Grapevine, City of Grapevine, to the Grapevine
Historic Preservation Ordinance 91-73 (Appendix G — Grapevine Code of Ordinances), as amended
for the following items:
1. Renovate existing house, construct new rooms in the second floor attic space with new dormer
and construct a new 1 % -story addition on the rear of house;
2. Construct new 2-car detached garage;
3. Relocate existing storage shed to rear comer of property;
as per attached plans following the Design Guidelines established for the property located
within the College Street Residential Historic District;
with the conditions a building permit is obtained from the Building Department and all exterior
materials, windows, doors and door hardware, light fixtures and paint colors be approved under
a separate Certificate of Appropriateness.
BACKGROUND:
Certificate of Appropriateness application #CA17-07 was submitted by the applicant Neal Cooper on
January 17, 2017 to renovate the existing house, construct new rooms in the second floor attic space
with a new dormer and construct a new 1 Y2 story addition on the rear of the house; construct a new
two car detached garage and relocate the existing storage shed to the rear corner of the property. The
house is a contributing structure to the College Street Residential Historic District. It was originally built
in 1888 and has an addition constructed in 1910. The Queen -Anne style house shows influence of the
renowned Texas architectural firm Sanguinet and Staats of Fort Worth. The house features a large
dormer with curved sides, located above the main entry, which recalls the Benjamin Richard Wall
House at 421 Smith Street attributed to the Sanquinet and Staats.
The plans for the house renovation, new additions and garage were developed by Architect Russell
Moran following Design Guidelines established for the property and the provisions of the 2013 update
to the Preservation Ordinance. Plans call for reconstructing the missing chimney on the east elevation;
details of the original house would be replicated in the new additions. The original house contained
1,628 square feet of living area. The existing house plus new additions would total 2,959 square feet
of living area. Adding this with the new 500 square foot garage and the 173 square foot relocated
storage shed would bring the total for all structures to 3,632 square feet, which is less than the 4,100
square feet maximum square footage of all structures on the site. The site is 11,690 square feet in
U:\Historic Preservation Commission\CAs\2017 CA\CA17-07.4.doc 221 West Cotlege Street.doc
September 5, 2024 (10:30AM)
size, building coverage is 31%, which is less than the maximum coverage of 40%.
Staff recommends approval of #CA17-07 to renovate the existing house, construct new rooms in the
second floor attic space with a new dormer and construct a new 1 % story addition on the rear of the
house; construct a new two car detached garage and relocate the existing storage shed to the rear
corner of the property as per the attached plans following the Design Guidelines established for the
College Street Residential Historic District and provisions of the 2013 update to the Preservation
Ordinance, with the conditions a building permit is obtained from the Building Department and all
exterior materials, windows, doors and door hardware, light fixtures and paint colors be approved
under a separate Certificate(s) of Appropriateness.
0:1Histortc Preservation CommissionTAs12017 CATA17-07.4.doc 221 West College Street.doc
February 15, 2017 (2:25PM)
ate
P(operty Owner Namt
v z1
Z
Phone:
Mobile: — Z50
Email:
Prope Address (inciu
Tenant Name/Occuoanc
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRP►TENESS APPLICA N
Number "k n
Phone Number
of Work to Be Done
[Drawings/Sketches Attached
Yes o No
Material Sample(s) Attached lease list
& Phone
Bbek j _ „ Lot
subdivision OQt'/aAyt - AWru a F
Phottoo rapin Attached
61 �+urrent o Historic
/ hereby -certify that this information is correct to the best of my knowledge and that the said work will be done In confommnce
with all submissions herein set forth, and in compliance with the City of Grapevines Historic Overlay District Ordinances and
Building Codes. APPROVAL OF A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRMTENESS DOES NOT CONSTJTUTE APPROVAL OF
OTHER REQUIRED BUILDING ,9ERMI7 S.
Signed x
WC.
Lia cF 0
0
or Contractor—� �-
Office Use
o I Approved with Conditions:
o
x
Chair— Historic Preservation Cnmmissim -
x
Biding Orrider
x
Date
-----NlsWc Preservaffm OHker
THIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT.
A SEPARATE BUILDING PERMIT MUST BE FILED AND APPROVED BY
THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT BEFORE STARTING WORK.
City of Grapevine Historic Preservation Department — 636 South Main Street, Grapevine, Texas 76051- (817) 4103556
012513
Tarrant Appraisal District
Real Estate
02/15/2017
ACCODnt Number. 01090453
Georeference: 16060-14•:B
Property Location: 221 W COLLEGE ST, GRAPEVINE, 76051
It er
Owner Information: NEWELLSUZANNE
NEWELL MILES
232 AUSTIN ST
GRAPEVINE TX 76051
2 Prier Owners
Legal Description: GRAPEVINE, CITY OF
Block 14 Lot:
N167.5'W81 12'3
Taxing Jurlsdieclons: 011 CRY OF GRAPEVINE
220TARRANTCOUNTY
906 GRAPEVINE-COLLEYVILIE ISD
224 TARRANTCOINTY HOSPITAL
225 TARRANT COUNTY COLLEGE
7this information is intended for reference only and is subject to change. It may not accurately reflect the complete
status of the account as actually carried in TAD's database
Certified Val
ues
ror Tax Year zoi
Land
kn '
01i T
arket Value
;53
143,82
f197
tad Value
53,
43
197
roxiniata Stsa
1.59
Acres
0.2
S
11,6901
11.
t Appraised value may be less than mar,E, . 3: oo�,, to state -man ated ir: ,ations on value increases
tt A zero value indicates that the property record has not yet been completed for the indicated tax year
tit Rounded
T1- represents one of a hierarchy of possible values ranKed in the following order: Recorded, Computed, System,
Calculated
5-Year Value Hict'nry
Tax Year
Appraised Land
Appraised Impr
Appraised Total
Market Land
Market MW
Market Told
2015
2014
2013
;50,00
$50,00
$50,
5147,60
$147,60
82 3
1197,60
197,E
$132 30
550,
SH
550.
f147,60
5347
2,
f197,6
197,60
132.3
2012
$S0,00
382
$132,90
F50,
fe3.
131.90
3011
550,00
f7176
12176
$52,
33
133,30
Deed Date: 12l1912016
Deed Page:
Deed Volume:
instrument: 0216296805
Year Built, 1920
Pet Complete: 1.00
TAD Map:
MAPSCO: TAR-027M
cvai iniuvice Beni:
Protest Deadline:
State Code: A Residentlal SingleFamliy
Garage Bays: 0
Central Air, N
Central Neat: N
Pool: N
TAD - Property Prior Owner
Page I of I
Tarrant Appraisal District
Rea! Estate
Data current as of 02/15/2017
Account Number: 01090453
Property Location: 221 W COLLEGE ST
Owner Information: NEWELL SUZANNE
NEWELL MILES
232 AUSTIN ST
GRAPEVINE TX 76051
Prior Owners
Name
Deed Date
Instrument
Deed
Vol
Deed
Page
kKENNEDY
4 EDGAR EST
12/31/1900
: 00000000000000
0000000
0000000
MCCALLW UM
PAU
10/25/2012' D213297892
0000000
0000000
If there is no deed date, Tarrant Appraisal District records do not contain the actual deed date.
1,44-41.., —, +o.t ..r./n�+c+nm/nrinr n,imar n}in`in}riTri_� OQOA';I ?/1l 517nt 7
'i.
. ,
AA
Ii
4C)ckiI-01
�( 221 W. College Street
W.COLLEGESTREET
WRa w.l
Power (Assumed Reference Searing)----
_ —� _ ___. C.M.^
N 0°OQr00" E 80.00' 1 �� �.9ono'oo' rs6.o6` I.R.F.
water o
Meter I3 1
SCALE
1"-30' I j 0
I
t�1 t4JS p, 60.25'_
Ir- j
to street X to
concrete16. i„ :"177' . e ( 0.5'
W ` ► i B (.
CWA - Eagle, Inc., ; P !-
z s arage urrdn V 1 a Texas corporation � w�
(no foundation a to
o O Instrt>Iment No. i �
•r �O i 1 1 O D214237066
E 11'
DRT.C.T.
E -I _ P r I
3 z l ~ok :u� .IV, ttlm 1 I
d 1 `instrument No.
i 213201892
Jaeni%
C. R.S. v� t
U I.R.F.1 S 90°00'00" W 80. I
r,j
' Ci pole
- - I3. C. Yancey-
�Volume
D.RT.C.T.
-l?>nm,e�eecardedb V.tmcx�551, 2V �� 1
%5'+99 ek ldl Qo nw.Ifeei d,b 1 �) 1 •',�'�.%
a.o. I �✓ I `ll �
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: The North 167.5 The of the West 80 feet of Lot 3, Block 14, Original Town of vGrapeAne,
Tarrant County, Texas, according to the plat filed in Book 309, Page 72, Deed Records, Tarrant County, Texas. j
I
I
Date. 112946 I1r AXD-c.MrCbwroft ay Mw=mi, LR.R-bRod rbmd: IAK-L ua fteFonwd;
TbewdwwVedbs,efiwnocf%dmid F.CP�Fe.xCmmr[bst 01840wbmdi7eade IAt-[t�itodSn lJl A®eRr wdm �.
c le-dsrWofddsmrvef. ,4SCNa 161145 7dk—Pempwd•AK%-9-VtneCaMW Alt hmd Nromd.e lAldb®eewwke I-
----c adccv4n.eewd.—X--(R.ee/%fmnyWl —me— (ovdvdpewer)
1pcfllic b ADNWIM
FLOOQ NOTE: bIsmplopWmlOA dropwdpwp dmrtibd beeoohool wviBaio dr l00.7.v �'
C1ent Fedend rrtlq Gad. Irwod�me ee. wwamRisvan wiled Pmniew7Mew2p.WAgI.7 Flood buwe�tt Rae i
MopCemoodq-PmdNo.410M01151t;p��m cntr4.c do ormq. Seprcd.M 009. �t
G.F.Noa WT)6�ft14670 be. q-IAknadvM.Zae'R•_ J
SURWIVORS CER.' WATIOIB
The WA&%Wedd.n WftCeNy do ddw wiscy w.w
ddw dq auk =dmb.®d.fdw: pmpetybptly
dece'bd b+
•(`'., °... rC:
>:_..
adk.orwe%e+d meobedlq
fRFo �q
....
bte.Mbvbv d:aso.ow. mumc�mbl.
�i�P 'G tP
orvMppbya�poranmv aetreNvdeltefwry
. -
dell tuwbem.fidrd oferaFtasbasnbaooa
.. ••••.. •.•••••••••••�...
A-.dbamy.b.,.toc.w-W.rl.wuoea.
J.R. JANUARY
S�i82 Pv.
��' ���
rthur
Surveying Ca
.�`�•
IMM a.M.uc Soce4S le 1000
flnpnvdwe, T'.- 7WSi
221 W. College street
Frpfes810ne1 rwend sln�5,yore
...120
- 817AIIA6
Fecd17ABIA8d7
Grapevine, Texas
FJm S�.i]UC-rswttvillc. TX 7ft1ST
tS.972T3t.9d39 •T}7{bFi I0 6380a
I onm.ca:nc�b1}.•: Emsi+lidrod ;95:t
-Iti
VNSQS Q1P/141i
�° `.. �° �• ° °� N HON TIHSSA
i
� t�
�C.Pti --o?
M
8JY'= i6A11 TTg
+wwa x�iau Mica acac
i
R,�
am_
N5
xv�o�e �Rssn
■
1
,#GP, 1-1 - p 7
'.
;.Epwamw
89MOD Isax TT8 LWWWAMLWdOW
RONfiOMM R1PAIRN M Alm - SEW
NVVOH TIRSSaH
Y
i
ILI
N
ILI,
z
0
Q.
�I
w
J
W
W
O
Z
P
X
w
C� o
Z
X Y
W 5
13- (�
V1
pr q 1W.o .0
( I
-`^° •�
Q
i
+�*� NVHOX TIZSSO
1
i
I
I
I
I
r------------------------
I
I
4=
L
I
� s n
I ' __ -
I
I - o ?
1WNAM
,,,;„- -
'. BSSIIO� i881t Ti8
SoNvamm
-�-�-
M
mm TAM mw am
-�►
UVxoR Tisssn
Y
�.Q
Q
i gSM01 LM IN ' trroo twa tser i
^ li
Q y
W
-A- C-A 1-7 -07
.ems. w....e.�..,-„
w� Aif777Aif1 TT�c+o�
4 Is, I11
z
0
F=-
a
W
J
W
LJ
9
N
l �.= I
M.
v�
I -
pox Tiassnu!
�5 �
�
1
r`
1
Favu
Rwnoo am T is , TOM M IvDd �
a Y
= �
4
7
I
!
a
Nvao awn
V
0
ISM AN { Cif OW
-----------�
�---T--------�---------------------XvId SA
i ,rp-a i
i
3trw .s I
iw i
i
r I J
I i
I I•
I
I I
I I Z
I �
o Q
fY
O
O
J
I.L
0 l
o
U
W
somw LM IWW'WADH ALOd 99M
RDNXaE= eVAElK OW 7� - LUM
b"OIK Tlxssn�
FA�
wj I
z
P
F-
Humoo Im TTZ IWW WAON IMd OW
ZDNRMM TWA=
IKTVUAW TTaccr
3Nn A183do2
3NII .—IH3dOdd
3Nn -i83dONd