HomeMy WebLinkAbout74546_10087_Quailty Collision Grapevine-Structural Eng Field Inspection-Corrections98
FIELD REPORT
By: Mark Dunlap, P.E.
Location of Site:
2051 State Hwy 121
Grapevine, TX 76051
Purpose of Site Visit:
Structural observation of construction progress
Date of Site Visit:
7 May 2025
Date Report Issued:
8 May 2025
Report Prepared for:
Roberto Rivera- Penney Design Group
Persons Contacted:
Chris Bowles-Superintendent
Alex Dornford- Assistant Superintendent
1. TRADES WORKING AT THE TIME OF OUR VISIT
• Tops of cmu walls being built.
• Structural steel framing, cmu walls, joist and deck approximately 85% complete.
• 2nd floor has only a few beams installed.
• Roof decking installed in most areas.
• Joist erection at drive lane area.
Noteable Portions of the Project that are complete
• All slabs and diamond joints are installed.
• Paint spray booth pits installed.
• Slabs all placed.
2. OBSERVATIONS/ ACTION ITEMS
• We observed that ALL the steel lintels that are deeper than 8” wide flange members, are missing
the required adjustable masonry anchors on each face of the lintel. These anchors will now have
to be field installed, either by welding or PAFS, before the veneer block can be set. See Photos
1 and 2, as examples of installed lintels.
• Angle lintels appear to be improperly installed. Where our documents called for an L1, which
requires a 4 x 3.5 x 5/16 angle per 4” wall thickness, we expected (3) lintels to be installed at a
12”wall, and with the 4” leg vertical. Instead, only (2) were installed and with the 4” leg
horizontally, leaving a gap where doors or windows can’t be properly attached when they will
2051 State Hwy 121 Structural Observations 7 May 2025
Grapevine, TX 76051
2
be placed. We will need to check if the strength of the installed lintels turned 90 degrees are
adequate where they occur. If they are not adequate, the proper number and orientation will
need to be installed. See Photos 3 and 4.
• The L2 lintels, requiring a 6 x 3.5 x 3/8 angle per 4” thickness of wall, were also installed with
only (2) angles, where (3) are required, and were turned 90 degrees with the 6” leg horizontally,
not vertically. We will also need to check if these are adequate, but we suspect they won’t be.,
Note that the installed condition shows that the horizontal legs protrude past the face of the
block walls since the actual dimension of 12” cmu is only 11 5/8”. At the exterior walls this will
be problematic catching rainwater as it runs down the exterior face of the cmu and gets trapped
by the steel protrusion. Regardless of structural capacity, these exterior lintels will require
replacement and installed properly with (3) members and the 6” leg vertically. See Photo 5 and
typically what we see sketched next to it.
• See screenshot of the architectural cross section on next page. Even though the design documents
from both TEC and PDG, and the steel shop drawings all indicate the BOD elevations correctly,
the mason missed an entire course and built the common wall bearing point too low. This will
affect the roof slope/ drainage substantially. We discussed 4 options:
o 1-use tapered insulation to create the proper slope for roof drainage.
o 2-use tapered insulation on the left side making the common wall the low point and then
create a cricket for roof drainage at the common wall that must be piped out to the side
walls, along with overflow scupper.
o 3-shore the left end of 11 left side joists, and cut down the bearing elevation by 7” to
maintain the intended slope, then re-attach joists to the new bearing elevation.
o 4- shore each set of joists along the common wall and provide HSS steel “Shims” to raise
up the middle bearing points. Weld the joist seats to the proposed HSS shims and HSS
shims to the existing steel bearing plates. Since there are a total of 23 joists that are all
bearing on separate plates, the number joists to raise up and weld to these shims is more
than double the option above.
• There wasn’t enough steel installed for the 2nd floor yet to warrant any comment on them. We
will need to do a virtual visit via Teams or FaceTime afer the floor, deck and shear studs are
installed, but before the concrete is placed at this level.
2051 State Hwy 121 Structural Observations 7 May 2025
Grapevine, TX 76051
3
Our visits are not a substitute for special inspections as required by the contract documents and the
building code. Please forward all inspection reports to us for our record.
Photo 1
Photo 2
2051 State Hwy 121 Structural Observations 7 May 2025
Grapevine, TX 76051
4
Photo 3 Photo 4
Photo 5
Corrections Photos
Corrections Photos